diff --git a/undercover/routes.py b/undercover/routes.py
index 2586ee8..f2957f8 100644
--- a/undercover/routes.py
+++ b/undercover/routes.py
@@ -140,7 +140,7 @@ def add_letter() -> Response:
     user = db.get_user(email_address)
 
     existing_letter_count = len(db.get_user_letters(user.id))
-    new_letter_name = f'Letter{existing_letter_count + 2}'
+    new_letter_name = f'Letter {existing_letter_count + 1}'
     default_form_json = jsonify(CLForm().to_cl_data()).get_data(True)
     db.add_letter(user.id, new_letter_name, default_form_json)
     return redirect(f'/?letter_name={new_letter_name}')
@@ -289,7 +289,7 @@ def generate_pdf() -> Response:
         letters = db.get_user_letters(user.id)
         letter_json = jsonify(data).get_data(True)
         if len(letters) == 0:
-            db.add_letter(user.id, 'My Cover Letter', letter_json)
+            db.add_letter(user.id, 'Letter1', letter_json)
         else:
             letter = letters[data.selectedLetter]
             # TODO: Support title editing